Posted by: kshayes513 | June 30, 2010

Legal Worldbuilding: Really Stupid Laws

Fireworks are now legal in Rhode Island. No, wait... Photo: Providence Journal/Bob Thayer

In a late night rush to pass  a stack of legislation before the summer break, the Rhode Island General Assembly recently passed a law legalizing, for the first time in the state, the sale and use of certain kinds of fireworks. Since locals can already buy fireworks in nearby states, the GA’s intent was to keep RI dollars and sales tax revenues at home.

Now this may appear to be a perfectly reasonable law, and in other circumstances, in other states, it would have been. But the lawmakers forgot two critical things:

1. They forgot to write the law carefully. They didn’t consult police, fire and other public safety officials, and they didn’t specify which kinds of fireworks are permitted. This left the door open for fireworks vendors to rush out an inventory of all kinds of risky devices including

2. The type of firework that caused Rhode Island’s deadliest disaster since the 1938 hurricane, The Station nightclub fire, in which 100 people died and over 200 more were injured. It’s hardly exaggerating to say that every single person in this tiny state has some personal connection to that fire. And Rhode Islanders don’t need their already long memories to keep the Station fresh in mind; the legal repercussions are still winding along 7 years later.

The uproar over the law, reported in the Providence Journal, lasted several days, until the state Fire Marshall stepped forward and defined what kinds of fireworks can be sold.

Public opinion (to judge by the comments on the Projo’s website) was about evenly split between, “How can they legalize those awful fireworks that caused so much tragedy?” and “The government should leave us alone and let us maim ourselves with any kind of fireworks we want.” (Yes, I’m exaggerating again. A little.)

It’s just this easy in the real world, for those in power to make bad laws, even with the best of intentions, and for those under their rule to overreact in numerous ways. Yes, even to good laws.

Now imagine that someone with lawmaking power in your world has created a new law. What  circumstances would make it a Really Stupid Law? What would make your world’s people overreact to the law? What power do they have to object to an RLS, or ignore it, or change it?

Extra help: two phenomena are nearly always present in lawmaking. First, the more laws are made prohibiting or controlling a certain kind of behavior, the more certain you can be that the lawmakers are not having any luck stopping people from doing it! Second, lawmakers very often have only one set of (usually short term) intentions in mind in creating a specific law, and never foresee any other consequences that might backfire from the same law.

If you need more inspiration, do a web search on “bad laws.” Just browsing the first 2 pages of hits will give you lots of ideas about how many ways people can see “bad laws.”  Google also brings up related topics like “funny laws” “unjust laws” and even “bad inlaws” – which in some societies might be grounds for their own set of laws!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: